ENGLISH EDITION / STRATEGIC ANALYSIS
Companies Want to Keep Their Senior Employees. But Do They Still Know How to Give Them a Future?
WeNold × JLPDécryptage — In-Depth Editorial Analysis
A company can retain its experienced executives while gradually ceasing to offer them genuine opportunities for the future. Reduced responsibilities, untapped skills, diminishing involvement in projects: this silent underutilisation of experienced human capital represents a blind spot in policies designed to retain older employees. Beyond its human consequences, this underutilisation also raises questions about organisational performance: how many skills, initiatives and opportunities for value creation remain untapped? Yet the challenge extends far beyond internal mobility. For some executives, the future lies in new responsibilities; for others, in knowledge transfer or a life project outside the company. The question facing CEOs, HR directors and executive committees is therefore no longer simply how many experienced employees they retain, but what opportunities their decisions genuinely help to create.
Keeping Experienced Employees Does Not Guarantee Them a Future
Companies have gradually made the employment of older workers a priority in social policy and skills management. Career-development discussions, training, knowledge-transfer initiatives and internal mobility programmes all reflect growing awareness of the issue.
But the existence of such measures does not demonstrate that they actually transform career paths.
According to a study published by Apec in April 2025, 89% of the medium-sized and large companies surveyed reported having introduced at least one measure to support older employees. Yet only 15% of executives aged 55 and over surveyed believed that their company had adapted its HR policies for older workers since the 2023 pension reform.
These figures concern two different populations and do not constitute a direct measure of effectiveness. Nevertheless, they highlight a possible gap between announced initiatives and the changes employees actually perceive.
Training creates no new opportunity if the skills acquired are never put into practice. A career discussion changes nothing if the aspirations expressed receive no response. An internal mobility policy remains theoretical when the necessary decisions are never made.
An HR policy should therefore be assessed not only by the initiatives it introduces, but by what it genuinely enables employees to achieve.
This distinction becomes particularly important when the continued presence of an experienced executive conceals a gradual reduction in their contribution.
The Silent Underutilisation of Experienced Human Capital
Professional sidelining does not always result from a sudden decision. It can develop quietly through an organisation’s everyday practices.
An executive retains their position but becomes less involved in strategic projects. Their responsibilities diminish. Their expertise is acknowledged without being fully used. Opportunities for professional development become increasingly limited, sometimes without any clear explanation.
This is what can be described as the silent underutilisation of experienced human capital.
Such a situation may amount to a form of gradual professional sidelining. However, it should neither automatically be equated with age discrimination nor inferred solely from a reduction in responsibilities.
Organisational restructuring, changing business requirements, economic constraints or an employee’s personal preferences may also explain certain developments.
The analysis must therefore be individual, evidence-based and open to different interpretations. Which responsibilities have disappeared? Which skills are no longer being used? What opportunities have been proposed? Does the employee want a change, or do they prefer stability?
Economic research sheds light on some of the organisational mechanisms that may aggravate these situations.
In a study published in August 2026 in the American Economic Review, economist Ingrid Haegele shows, using data from a large company, that some managers may have incentives to retain high-performing employees within their teams, even at the expense of internal mobility.
This research does not measure the professional sidelining of experienced French executives. It does, however, reveal a potential conflict between a department’s immediate performance and the more effective deployment of skills across the organisation.
The issue therefore extends beyond recognition alone.
A company can acknowledge the value of an experienced executive while making decisions that prevent that value from finding new applications.
Senior leadership is responsible for identifying these contradictions and making the necessary decisions to resolve them.
Unlocking Experience to Open Up Three Paths Towards the Future
An Apec survey published in 2024, conducted among 820 private-sector executives aged 55 and over, found that 91% considered themselves engaged in their work, while 38% believed they had fewer opportunities for career progression than before.
These findings do not demonstrate that all experienced executives wish to change roles. They highlight the diversity of individual circumstances.
Some are looking for new challenges. Others wish to deepen their expertise, maintain their current responsibilities or gradually prepare for a transition.
The challenge is therefore to bring to light the wealth of human experience, skills and aspirations of each experienced executive, rather than impose a single model for the second half of their career.
This is where the approach championed by WeNold stands out, structured around three complementary pathways.
Repositioning and new opportunities. This may involve enriching existing responsibilities, contributing to a cross-functional project, developing new skills or preparing for an appropriate internal move.
Organised transfer of human capital. Accumulated knowledge can support operational continuity, mentoring and succession planning. However, passing on knowledge should not become the only future offered to employees once they reach a certain age.
Building a future life project. Experience can also provide the foundation for a different activity, an external career transition or a meaningful personal commitment.
These three pathways are neither mutually exclusive nor necessarily sequential. An executive can pass on knowledge while continuing to learn, undertake a new assignment while preparing for a career change, or choose to remain in their current position.
The value of personalised support lies precisely in its ability to help a suitable path emerge without determining it in advance.
A Future Life Project: A New Horizon for HR Policies
This is perhaps the most profound change companies need to consider.
Traditionally, the success of talent-management policies has been assessed through employee retention, internal mobility and succession planning.
Yet retaining an employee is not necessarily the best response to their aspirations or the organisation’s future needs.
An experienced executive may wish to establish a consulting business, launch a company, take part in skills-based volunteering initiatives or become involved in a non-profit organisation.
Others may envisage a career change, a combination of different professional and personal commitments, or a gradual transition towards a different way of life.
These opportunities are not merely fallback options for a career coming to an end. They can represent genuinely chosen projects, built upon the individual’s experience, skills and motivations.
But such projects require serious preparation.
A credible process begins by clarifying the executive’s aspirations and constraints. It continues by assessing transferable skills, the project’s economic viability and any additional training requirements.
The next stage involves preparing the transition: establishing a timetable, transferring responsibilities, organising succession arrangements and exploring opportunities for testing the new direction where feasible.
For the company, supporting a chosen departure can help secure critical knowledge and anticipate organisational changes more effectively.
For the employee, this preparation can reduce uncertainty and make the transition from an initial intention to a viable project easier.
These benefits are, of course, not guaranteed. Entrepreneurship involves risks; changing careers may take time; and voluntary work does not necessarily replace paid employment.
A successful transition therefore depends on freedom of choice, project feasibility and clearly defined commitments from everyone involved.
A company can help enhance the value of an executive’s experience even when their professional future develops beyond its own workforce.
This is a fundamental difference between a policy focused on retaining employees and an approach dedicated to developing human capital.
Five Decisions to Turn Experience into Concrete Opportunities
For CEOs, HR directors and managers, the challenge is no longer simply to recognise a problem. It is to establish a method for moving from diagnosis to action.
Practical Framework — Five Immediately Actionable Levers
01 — Identify Skills and Aspirations
Look beyond job descriptions to understand an executive’s expertise, achievements, transferable skills and professional ambitions.
Key question: Do we know what our experienced employees still want to achieve?
02 — Detect Underutilisation
Identify declining responsibilities, skills that are not being fully deployed, blocked mobility opportunities and organisational obstacles. Examine each situation individually.
Key question: Could an apparently stable position conceal unwanted professional sidelining?
03 — Develop Several Future Pathways
Explore repositioning opportunities, knowledge transfer, new assignments or a transition towards a future life project. Assess their feasibility together with the employee.
Key question: Are we offering genuine choices, or merely extending an employee’s current position?
04 — Make Decision-Makers Accountable
Identify who is responsible for decisions, the resources required, knowledge-transfer arrangements and deadlines. Provide support tailored to the chosen pathway.
Key question: Who actually has the authority to turn an opportunity into a decision?
05 — Measure Outcomes for Both Parties
Assess the skills deployed, contributions delivered, employee satisfaction, operational continuity and, where relevant, progress towards an external project, as well as the value created or preserved wherever it can be measured objectively.
Key question: What actually happened after we made our decision?
These five levers form a framework for diagnosis and action, not a guarantee of success.
They can also provide a starting point for a discussion between a company and WeNold about the value of its experienced human capital, the opportunities available and the situations requiring individualised support.
For Executive Committees, the Question Is Now One of Results
The underutilisation of skills may represent an economic risk. However, it would be misleading to automatically equate that risk with a financial loss corresponding to an employee’s salary.
Our research did not identify a sufficiently robust national estimate of the average cost of underutilising experienced executives in France.
A leadership team can nevertheless compare several decisions in response to a genuine business need: maintaining the existing organisation, repositioning an employee, investing in training, organising knowledge transfer, recruiting or supporting an external transition.
Each option involves different costs, constraints and potential outcomes.
Executive committees are responsible for making these trade-offs explicit and assessing their consequences.
This requirement also applies to difficult decisions. An internal move may be inappropriate. Training may not lead to a new assignment. A life project may need to be reconsidered. Freely chosen stability may be an entirely satisfactory outcome.
The objective is not to multiply changes, but to ensure that decisions are understood, feasible and consistent with the needs of everyone involved.
This is precisely the philosophy behind WeNold: revealing experienced human capital, organising its contribution or transfer, and enabling new opportunities to emerge, including the development of a future life project.
Such an approach cannot be reduced to employee retention or professional mobility.
It requires recognising experienced executives as active participants in shaping their own futures, while companies act as responsible partners capable of making meaningful decisions.
Ultimately, the maturity of an HR policy cannot be measured solely by the number of experienced employees it retains.
It must also be judged by its ability to identify underutilised skills, offer genuine alternatives and support freely chosen career and life paths.
A company generally knows how many experienced executives it employs.
But does it know how many still have a future they have genuinely chosen — and that the company is actively helping them to build?
Main Documentary Sources
- Apec, April 2024 — Projections professionnelles des cadres séniors. Survey conducted in 2023 among 820 private-sector executives aged 55 and over.
- Apec, April 2025 — Cadres seniors : un mouvement s’amorce dans les entreprises.
- Ingrid Haegele, August 2026 — Talent Hoarding in Organizations, American Economic Review.
Documentary research and writing: JLPDécryptage for WeNold — November 2026.