Read the interview
René Villemure, smiling, in a grey jacket and pink striped tie, in his MP’s office in front of a Quebec flag

IN-DEPTH INTERVIEW · CORPORATE EDITORIAL

RENÉ VILLEMURE

ETHICS • POWER • ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE • RESPONSIBILITY

FrançaisEnglish

Read the interview

© Équipe René Villemure

INTRODUCTION

What remains of ethics when rules are no longer enough, political power demands compromise, and artificial intelligence promises to think for us? René Villemure has explored these questions for nearly three decades. Founder of the Quebec Institute of Applied Ethics in 1998 and a recognised voice in governance consulting, he advised organisations before entering Canada’s House of Commons. Elected as a Bloc Québécois MP for Trois-Rivières in 2021, he served as vice-chair of the parliamentary committee responsible for access to information, privacy and ethics. In this interview with JLPDécryptage, he reflects on serious illness, his independence from paying clients, the tensions of political life and what he sees as a major risk of AI: the gradual surrender of human judgment. His answers reveal a central conviction: ethics is neither mere compliance nor a public display of principles. It requires us to think, to discuss and, at times, to refuse.

THE IN-DEPTH INTERVIEW

01ILLNESS AND THE CHOICE TO STEP BACK

JLPDécryptage

In 2025, as you were seeking another term in office, you had to put your health ahead of the election campaign. You have said that you do not regret that decision. Did this experience change the way you think about ethics—not only as a reflection on what we should do, but also on what we must sometimes be prepared to give up?

René Villemure

Canadian elections are not held on fixed dates. The government in office may decide, according to its own agenda and subject to certain procedures, to call an election when it sees fit. In this context, unless they express a wish to the contrary, sitting MPs are automatically registered as candidates when an election is called.

As soon as I learned how serious my medical condition was, when rumours of an election were circulating but before one had actually been called, I decided to put my health ahead of all my professional obligations. In fact, I underwent my first surgical procedure during the election campaign, before polling day. Although my name could no longer be removed from the ballot at that stage, I did not campaign to defend my seat and, as a result, I was defeated. At no point, however, have I regretted choosing to put my health before my position as an MP.

Recovering from that operation—which was, incidentally, the first in a series of major procedures—naturally kept me in bed. But a physical limitation, however severe, does not prevent philosophical or ethical reflection. Anyone who has been through a similar ordeal will tell you that their perspective on the world has changed; in that respect, I am no different. I nevertheless took the opportunity to reflect on broader ethical issues, such as the many impacts—often left unspoken—of artificial intelligence on society, on democracy as we practise it today, and on interference by certain states in the political processes of other states, notably through disinformation or corruption.

In short, I moved from a concern with ethics as applied to the day-to-day work of Parliament to a societal and global perspective on ethical issues in a rapidly changing world. I am currently writing a book about democracy in an age of scoundrelism. There is no shortage of material.

02DOES ETHICS NEED BOUNDARIES?

JLPDécryptage

You distinguish ethics from morality and professional codes of conduct: ethics comes into play particularly when rules are inadequate, unclear or contradictory. But how can we prevent thinking “outside the rules” from becoming a convenient justification for decisions driven by individual self-interest? What, in your view, is the foundation of genuinely ethical judgment?

René Villemure

That is a very relevant question, and I have had many opportunities to reflect on it over the years.

First, ethical reflection is a search for what is right in the circumstances, within a particular context at a particular moment. Ethics comes into play when a decision must be made in a situation we might describe as irregular. Such situations can be described as follows:

  • There is no rule or directive applicable to the situation in question;
  • Existing rules or directives are unclear or say nothing about how to act in the circumstances;
  • In large organisations or governments, often because of regulatory proliferation, two rules exist but applying them strictly produces a contradiction;
  • Applying a rule to the letter would result in an injustice.

It is therefore essential to understand that ethical reflection always takes place in an “irregular” context, rather than a “general” or “regular” one, where the appropriate course is to apply the rules or directives. In the latter case, we are dealing with compliance or professional conduct, not ethics as such.

Although ethics is often associated with structures (codes, directives, compliance or certification), ethics is more a matter of culture. It is worth noting that certain ethical breaches can provoke public outrage in one culture but not in another. This does not mean that ethics and what is right are matters of personal preference or subjectivity. Rather, ethics can only be considered within a given context, and assessments of that context may vary across cultures. One example would be comparing the ethical situation in a peaceful and prosperous Western country with that of a country actively at war with its neighbour. Ethical concerns remain in both cases, but the way those concerns are viewed may shift somewhat, like light passing through a prism, and be perceived differently in that context.

To avoid relativism, trivialisation or the instrumentalisation of ethics, it must rest on clear, workable principles that are actually put into practice. These principles are called “values”. It is therefore social or corporate values—not personal values—that should underpin an ethical decision. This is why the meaning of each value must be absolutely clear and precise; without such clarity, relativism will prevail.

Finally, we must not forget the importance of setting an example. In ethics, the example must come from the top of a company’s or a state’s hierarchy. Without such leadership, ethics can only be a façade—a showcase ethics, or mere aesthetics.

03FREEDOM OF CONSCIENCE UNDER POLITICAL PRESSURE

JLPDécryptage

After years of advising organisations on ethical matters, you served in the House of Commons as a member of the Bloc Québécois. Within a political party, individual convictions meet collective discipline and political compromise. Did you experience situations in which these demands came into conflict? What did you learn about the possibilities—and the limits—of ethics in the exercise of power?

René Villemure

In politics, it is essential to distinguish between what citizens and the media think about politics or politicians and the reality. There is often an enormous gap between the two.

I joined the Bloc Québécois at the request of its leader, who had been a personal friend for many years. When he invited me, he knew he was dealing with an independent thinker and that I would not leave that characteristic behind. Indeed, it was because of my reputation for independent thinking and integrity that he asked me to join the party, so that I could advise the entire caucus and assist the executive of the Bloc’s parliamentary wing in defining its strategies, tactics and positions.

My experience in ethics, international relations, the Francophonie and privacy protection lent additional weight to the party’s positions.

Before going further, it is important to understand that the Bloc Québécois is a federal political party sitting in Canada’s Parliament in Ottawa, and the only political party whose exclusive mission is to represent Quebec’s interests in the Canadian Parliament. The Bloc Québécois is therefore an opposition party—a third opposition party—and operates only in the province of Quebec. It does not aspire to form the government of Canada; rather, it seeks to ensure that decisions made in the Canadian Parliament serve Quebec’s interests. This last point is very important: whereas in a governing party all elected members, whoever they may be, are strictly bound by party discipline and the party line, with no exceptions or discussion, debates within the Bloc Québécois are more collegial.

Despite this dynamic, there were occasions when I disagreed with a position the party was considering; each time, however, I was able to express my disagreement without any difficulty. There were even occasions when, thanks to my experience and the strength of my arguments, I persuaded the entire caucus to adopt my position, which then became the party’s “new position”.

In short, I never felt any constraint on expressing my positions or my occasional disagreements. If, after deliberation, the party had chosen to maintain a position with which I disagreed, I would have abstained from voting on it. I am aware, however, that not everyone enjoyed the same latitude in those circumstances; for me, it was one of the conditions of entering politics.

04ADVISING THOSE WHO PAY YOU

JLPDécryptage

You have built an ethics consultancy serving organisations and executives. How do you preserve your independence when a client paying for your work must hear an uncomfortable diagnosis? Have you ever had to turn down an assignment or defend a conclusion at the risk of losing a professional relationship?

René Villemure

I began my career in ethics nearly 30 years ago, at a time when ethicists scarcely existed outside medical circles. My practice with governments and major corporations developed over time. Most major assignments came through satisfied clients who readily recommended my services because they considered them to be of high quality. It was these clients who, over the course of successive assignments, determined that I was “worthy of trust”.

From the very beginning of my career, it was clear that the outcome of an assignment or an ethical assessment would never be watered down or concealed for financial reasons.

Several companies, especially in the early days, asked me to lower the demands of certain recommendations. My answer was always the same: “If a point in the assessment is unclear, I can certainly express it differently. If you do not like a point in the assessment, there is nothing I can do about that.”

Having made that position very clear, I know that several companies chose to use other providers who were, perhaps, less demanding in their recommendations.

There was even a case in which a large company hired me for a complex assignment and it eventually emerged that the person who had hired me was themselves the source of the ethical problem. Naturally, that person asked me to suppress the recommendation, threatening not to pay me for the final phase of the work if I did not comply. I refused outright and even issued a credit note for the final phase of the assignment. I imagine that person had to explain that credit note to their superior…

I am proud to say that my reputation and integrity have never been for sale. That was a red line, not open to negotiation.

I have already turned down a number of assignments because I knew in advance that the client wanted a whitewash report signed by a recognised expert. I left it to others to compromise themselves.

In 2019, the Université du Québec awarded me an honorary doctorate in recognition of the exceptional nature of my achievements in ethics, which I believe attests to my integrity throughout my career.

05NATURAL INTELLIGENCE AFTER AI

JLPDécryptage

As early as 2018, you warned of a danger less spectacular than that posed by machines: human beings gradually giving up thinking for themselves. Today, AI operates in areas where decisions can have major consequences. At what point does technical assistance become a surrender of judgment? And how can genuine human responsibility be maintained when decisions depend on systems that are difficult to understand?

René Villemure

Much is said about the danger posed by AI agents that might break out of their assigned boundaries and do harm or cause damage. In response to that danger, people talk about developing responsible AI. But is that not missing the forest for the trees? Instead of asking what might happen if AI malfunctions, I believe we should ask what might happen if AI works exactly as intended.

Around the world, we can read statistics about declining reading habits; universities have already begun adapting their required reading lists to students who can no longer, or no longer want to, read. The fashionable author of the moment has replaced Tolstoy, who is deemed too difficult.

We now know that AI can even write a novel worthy of winning prestigious literary prizes. Far be it from me to judge the quality of books or works of art produced by AI, but I am extremely concerned about the intellectual laziness generated by the widespread use of AI. Why think when ChatGPT can do it? Why write a letter when ChatGPT can do it?

The main danger of AI does not lie in its going rogue. Rather, it lies in its accelerating contribution to the dumbing down of society—or, to put it differently, to the loss of concentration, curiosity and knowledge that individuals once accumulated.

The danger of AI is that it works exactly as intended.

Google replaced the dictionary; Wikipedia replaced Google. Now comes AI, promising to answer everything, immediately and perfectly, and therefore to replace individual judgment. What will become of critical thinking? What will become of individual responsibility? For the moment, these issues are being overlooked.

Although AI has demonstrated its value in certain fields, AI does not reason; it compiles answers from its immense database and chooses to give you a particular answer. AI therefore responds according to its algorithm, with its inherent biases, rather than according to a vision of Good or Evil, Right or Wrong.

Finally, we must not forget that AI is the product of a single, Western, English-speaking way of thinking.

From an ethical standpoint, AI cannot replace human judgment.

06REBUILDING OUR SHARED POINTS OF REFERENCE

JLPDécryptage

You have described the weakening of certain traditional frameworks of reference. Yet their decline has also allowed greater pluralism and individual freedom. How can we build shared ethical reference points without trying to restore a single moral authority? What principles, in your view, should hold a deeply diverse society together?

René Villemure

I mentioned earlier that ethics is a matter of culture before it is a matter of structure. Yet most large organisations approach ethics by laying down commandments bordering on legal rules and seeking compliance with them. Ethics is a reflection on the ultimate purpose and on the choice of means best suited to achieving it.

Ethical reflection therefore cannot be reduced to a series of “do nots”; however long the list, it will never be complete. We absolutely must restore the value of critical thinking rather than mere compliance.

Throughout my career, and especially during my travels across several continents, I encountered many different ways of thinking and seeing the world. At first sight, the differences between societies seemed immense. Yet, as discussions progressed and I introduced an ethical vocabulary to the people I met, I realised that if we raised the discussion to the level of its ultimate purpose—rather than focusing on the means—the similarities were more numerous than one might initially think; sometimes there were even more similarities than differences.

It is therefore discussion that allows ideas to meet, a shared meaning to be given to conduct, and that construction of meaning to become the foundation of ethical reflection.

Ethics can never exist where one party seeks to impose its vision of Good on the other, particularly when the discussion concerns only the means rather than the ultimate purpose.

Where many people seek to say “do not do that”, the ethicist instead asks: “What should we do?” While many believe that an ethicist’s role is to provide answers to questions, that role actually consists in a certain art of asking questions.

For example, I have often observed that even when several people disagree about “how to do it”, by the end of a discussion many of them come together around the question “What should we do to do the right thing?”

When the ultimate purpose, mission and reason for being are shared, disagreements are often only superficial and rarely irreconcilable. The task then becomes to help the parties articulate their thinking and turn superficial disagreement into agreement.

07THE ETHICIST CONFRONTS HIS OWN DECISIONS

JLPDécryptage

You have devoted your career to examining the gap between stated principles and actual behaviour. Your time in politics—with its controversies, difficult choices and eventual electoral defeat—placed you in the position of someone whose own actions were subject to public judgment. Looking back, is there a decision or public statement you would approach differently today? What does self-criticism teach someone whose profession is to advise others?

René Villemure

My time in politics gave me an opportunity to see how ideas take shape before becoming a policy or a law. One of the dangers that is often present today is blind partisanship. I will return to that.

As mentioned earlier, ethics requires a broad perspective, an ability to assess the factors at play and a willingness to act in the public interest. The ethicist is, in a sense, an expert in questioning and a facilitator of decision-making.

Before entering politics, I had the opportunity to work in some thirty countries, with both major private organisations and governments, on public security, diplomacy, sensitive problem-solving and conflict situations, working with CEOs as well as heads of state. Those years helped me develop a more discerning view of human conduct and the behaviour of organisations, societies and governments. I entered politics with that experience behind me.

First, it must be said that ethicists are not numerous in politics—I was the only one among the MPs—so I brought an experienced, reflective perspective to discussions with fellow parliamentarians, who often came from legal or community backgrounds. Moreover, my interventions always sought to strengthen or prioritise the common good, whereas many of my counterparts in the major governing parties aimed for partisan decisions, often short-term ones that suited the party in power but were far removed from the population’s real interests. All too often, partisanship or interests other than those of the population guide the decisions of many governments—and an increasing number of them.

Within my political party, I was given the role of constructive challenger, to encourage my colleagues to broaden their perspective on the issues on which we had to take a position.

As vice-chair of the Canadian Parliament’s Standing Committee on Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics, I was also often able to serve as an expert or point of reference on the matters under discussion. My colleagues on the committee were not specialists in these fields and recognised and appreciated the different perspectives I brought when questioning witnesses or during deliberations. Parliamentary committees consist of members from all parties represented in the House of Commons, in proportion to their numbers of MPs, and are tasked with investigating or legislating on a specific subject.

On the Standing Committee on Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics, of which I was a member, I was the only Bloc Québécois representative. That is why one of my greatest sources of pride is having frequently succeeded in securing unanimous adoption—that is, without dissent—of the reports produced by the committee. That is a rare achievement.

Having always pursued the public interest in the House of Commons, in committee work and in public statements, I do not regret any of the words I spoke during my term as an MP.

My only regret is the lack of appetite shown by the governing party for adopting the recommendations put forward in those reports. That remains a great disappointment to me.

08COURAGE AS THE LAST GUIDING PRINCIPLE

JLPDécryptage

You have written about courage and the risk of cynicism when courage is lacking. After your career as an ethicist, your parliamentary experience and the ordeals you have faced, which conviction do you now find most difficult to defend in public life? And what should a human being never agree to sacrifice in the name of efficiency, security or belonging to a group?

René Villemure

I deplore the fact that more and more decisions are being made by a small circle of unelected people surrounding prime ministers or presidents. MPs from the governing party are too often reduced to voting on laws in whose development they played little part, thereby eliminating any opportunity for courage.

In practice, they are handed a text to defend or criticise and, without fully understanding its implications, they defend or criticise it with desperate energy. This dismal spectacle is one of blind partisanship and an almost total absence of critical thinking.

There was a time when the thinking of elected representatives mattered much more; they were also chosen for their competence and oratorical ability. I sometimes have the impression that, for several years now, some have been chosen solely because of their diversity or their docility. I believe that is a mistake.

The role of a Bloc Québécois MP is to defend Quebec’s best interests. That role cannot be sacrificed at any price, even though it inevitably creates friction in a Parliament where the English-speaking majority regards several of Quebec’s positions as quaint or unimportant.

Being a Bloc Québécois MP entails a constantly renewed commitment to preserving the distinctive nature of Francophone culture and values and, above all, Quebec’s autonomy in the face of Anglo-Saxon assimilation actively promoted by a predatory federalism.

In Parliament, for elected representatives of every party, it should be forbidden not to think.

René Villemure in a blue jacket on a busy pedestrian street at sunset
© Équipe René Villemure
Official website — ethique.net

ABOUT RENÉ VILLEMURE

A Quebec ethicist, author and speaker, René Villemure has worked in applied ethics, governance and strategic reflection since 1998. He founded the Quebec Institute of Applied Ethics, which he led until 2012, and heads Éthikos, a think tank and consultancy based in the Montreal area.

According to the professional history provided on LinkedIn, he has been a founding member of Cercle K2 since December 2017. Cercle K2 confirms his membership on its website and describes his work in foresight, strategic ethics and governance. He also taught ethical governance at Université Laval’s Collège des administrateurs de sociétés (2009–2020) and in the Chartered Directors programme at The Directors College, affiliated with McMaster University (2018–2021).

Elected as a federal Bloc Québécois MP for Trois-Rivières in September 2021, he served in the House of Commons until April 2025. He was vice-chair of the Standing Committee on Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics and took part in parliamentary work on Canada–China relations. His professional history also lists responsibilities in parliamentary Francophonie affairs.

He studied philosophy at the Université de Sherbrooke and received an honorary doctorate from the Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières in 2019 in recognition of his achievements in ethics. His publications include “L’éthique pour tous… même vous !” (2019). In this interview, he reveals that he is working on a new book about democracy in an age of “scoundrelism”.

Website: https://www.ethique.net | LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/renevillemure/

Interview by Julien Laurenceau Porte

SOURCES AND VERIFICATION

EDITORIAL NOTE — This is an English translation of René Villemure’s French answers, not a separate English-language interview. Statements about artificial intelligence, political parties and Canadian federalism express the interviewee’s views, not independent findings by JLPDécryptage. Photographs supplied for this interview: credit “Équipe René Villemure”.